Attorney Statistics for Cases in Our Database
Win Rate
Dugald has won an estimated 56.90% of legal cases in our database that were fully litigated. This lawyer has won at least 33 legal cases and lost at least 25 legal cases. Win rates vary widely between different types of cases, so please view this attorney's individual practice area results below for more information.
The estimated win rate is computed based on fully litigated cases, meaning cases that were pursued to a win or loss. It does not count other case outcomes such as settlements and plea bargains.
Experience
Dugald has handled at least 74 legal cases in our database.
Settlement Rate
Dugald settles an estimated 0.00% of legal cases and litigates 100.00% of legal cases to conclusion, based on our database. This lawyer has settled at least 0 legal cases and litigated to conclusion at least 58 legal cases.
For purposes of this chart, both settlements and plea bargains are counted as settlements, as opposed to cases litigated to conclusion.
Win Rate Comparison
Dugald's win rate is higher than the average win rate for attorneys handling legal cases primarily for businesses and institutions in our database. The bar graph shows Dugald's win rate compared to the average.
Experience Comparison
Dugald has handled more legal cases than the average attorney handling legal cases primarily for businesses and institutions in our database.
Summary
Dugald has a solid win rate (estimated) in legal cases in our database and is rated an excellent 4.5 or 4.0 stars in several practice areas. Much more detailed information about this lawyer is presented in the charts and tables below.
Our Ratings
We rate Dugald's performance in each case type, and we also show the attorney's case outcomes used to compute our rating. The data in the following table are AI-computed estimates based on cases in our database.
Click on the details button below to learn more about the attorney's rating and performance in that case type.
| # | Case Type |
Rating
|
Win Rate |
Settlement / Plea Rate |
Total Cases | Wins | Losses | Settled |
Plea Bargain |
Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Overall
|
4.5 | 56.90% | 0.00% | 74 | 33 | 25 | 0 | 0 | Details |
| 2 |
Civil
|
4.5 | 58.18% | 0.00% | 71 | 32 | 23 | 0 | 0 | Details |
| 3 |
Appeal
|
4.5 | 56.00% | 0.00% | 52 | 28 | 22 | 0 | 0 | Details |
| 4 |
Criminal
|
4.0 | 0.00% | 3 | 0 | 0 | Details | |||
| 5 |
Business
|
3.5 | 0.00% | 15 | 0 | 0 | Details | |||
| 6 |
Employment
|
3.0 | 0.00% | 1 | 0 | 0 | Details | |||
| 7 |
Contract
|
0.00% | 1 | 0 | 0 | Details |
Reviews
Similar Attorneys near Ashburn
Cases
Our case-reading artificial intelligence program has analyzed Dugald's cases from our database and summarized them in the following table. Click the details button for a detailed record of the case.
Any systematic or automated data collection from this website is strictly prohibited. Submit corrections to support@justicetoolbox.com.
Filters applied
All Case Types
All Outcomes
| # | Case Name | Number | Filing Date | For Party | Court | Case Type |
Outcome Detail |
Outcome (AI-estimated) |
Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A.B. Dick Company, Appellant/cross-Appellee v. Burroughs Corporation, Appellee/cross-Appellant | 798 F.2d 1392, Nos. 86-562, 86-645. | 08/18/1986 | Appellant/cros-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 2 | Ransburg Corp. v. Champion Spark Plug Co. | 648 F. Supp. 1040, No. 86 C 103. | 06/30/1986 | Defendant | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Business Civil Employment | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 3 | AB Dick Co. v. Burroughs Corp. | 617 F. Supp. 1382, No. 78 C 75. | 09/10/1985 | Defendant | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Business Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 4 | John Deere Limited and Deere & Company v. Sperry Corporation | 754 F.2d 132, No. 84-1070. | 02/05/1985 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 5 | Jon E. Kinzenbaw and Kinze Manufacturing, Inc. v. Deere & Company and Eugene G. Keeton | 741 F.2d 383, Nos. 83-1424, 84-523. | 08/07/1984 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 6 | Litton Systems, Inc. v. Whirlpool Corporation | 728 F.2d 1423, No. 83-1004. | 02/14/1984 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 7 | Mead Digital Systems, Inc. Mead Corporation, Cross-Appellant v. A.B. Dick Company and Gould, Inc., Cross-Appellees | 723 F.2d 455, Nos. 82-3163, 82-3178. | 12/08/1983 | Plaintiff-appellant / Defendan | Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 8 | Hughes Aircraft Company v. The United States | 717 F.2d 1351, No. 426-73. | 09/20/1983 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit | Appeal Criminal | -- | Loss | Details |
| 9 | A.B. Dick Company v. Burroughs Corporation | 713 F.2d 700, No. 83-595. | 07/27/1983 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 10 | Brunswick Corporation v. Champion Spark Plug Company | 689 F.2d 740, No. 81-1957. | 09/28/1982 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 11 | Deere & Company v. International Harvester Company | 658 F.2d 1137, No. 80-2208. | 11/02/1981 | Plaintiff-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 12 | Hughes Aircraft Co., Cross-Appellees v. Messerschmitt-Boelkow-Blohm, Gmbh, Cross-Appellant | 625 F.2d 580, No. 78-1263. | 09/08/1980 | Plaintiff-appellant / Cros-app | Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 13 | Toro Co. v. Textron, Inc. | 499 F. Supp. 241, No. 78-50. | 09/05/1980 | Defendant | District Court, D. Delaware | Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 14 | Eltra Corporation v. Basic Incorporated | 599 F.2d 745, No. 77-3364. | 06/18/1979 | Plaintiff-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 15 | Panduit Corporation v. Dennison Manufacturing Company | 593 F.2d 800, No. 77-1688. | 03/12/1979 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 16 | Deere & Company, and Cross-Appellant v. Hesston Corporation, and Cross-Appellee | 593 F.2d 956, Nos. 77-1561, 77-1562. | 03/09/1979 | Plaintiff-appellee / Cros-appe | Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 17 | Bell Telephone Laboratories, Incorporated v. Hughes Aircraft Company, and General Instrument Corporation | 564 F.2d 654, No. 77-1061. | 10/25/1977 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 18 | Dresser Industries, Inc. v. Eltra Corp. | 432 F. Supp. 153, No. C 69-613. | 06/11/1977 | Defendant | District Court, N.D. Ohio | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 19 | Deere & Co. v. Hesston Corp. | 456 F. Supp. 520, No. C 299-73. | 05/04/1977 | Plaintiff | District Court, D. Utah | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 20 | Union Carbide Corporation v. Borg-Warner Corporation and Sund-Borg MacHines Corporation, Defendants | 550 F.2d 355, No. 75-2263. | 01/27/1977 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 21 | Tokyo Shibaura Electric Co. Ltd. v. Zenith Radio Corporation | 548 F.2d 88, No. 76-1237. | 01/07/1977 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 22 | Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. v. Zenith Radio Corporation and the Rauland Corporation | 537 F.2d 896, No. 75--2157. | 08/17/1976 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 23 | Bell Tel. Laboratories, Inc. v. Hughes Aircraft Co. | 422 F. Supp. 372, No. 74-238. | 07/19/1976 | Defendant | District Court, D. Delaware | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 24 | Tokyo Shibaura Elec. Co., Ltd. v. Zenith Radio Corp. | 404 F. Supp. 547, No. 4672. | 11/07/1975 | Defendant | District Court, D. Delaware | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 25 | Deere & Company v. Sperry Rand Corporation | 513 F.2d 1131, No. 71-1897. | 05/30/1975 | Plaintiff-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 26 | Halliburton Company v. The Dow Chemical Company | 514 F.2d 377, No. 74-1343. | 04/28/1975 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 27 | COLUMBIA BROADCAST. SYS., INC. v. Zenith Radio Corp. | 391 F. Supp. 780, No. 71 C 687. | 03/18/1975 | Defendant | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 28 | CPC International, Inc. v. Standard Brands Inc. | 385 F. Supp. 1057, No. 4196. | 11/26/1974 | Plaintiff | District Court, D. Delaware | Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 29 | Rocco Anthony Marrese and William T. O'Sullivan v. Richard's Medical Equipment, Inc., and Airco, Inc. | 504 F.2d 479, No. 73-1760. | 10/21/1974 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 30 | HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY v. General Instrument Corp. | 374 F. Supp. 1166, No. 4379. | 04/23/1974 | Plaintiff | District Court, D. Delaware | Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 31 | Popeil Brothers, Inc. v. Schick Electric, Inc. | 494 F.2d 162, Nos. 73-1050 to 73-1053. | 03/21/1974 | Plaintiff-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 32 | Eugene A. Wahl and Vibra Screw, Inc. v. Vibranetics, Inc. | 474 F.2d 971, No. 72-1661. | 03/02/1973 | Plaintiff-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 33 | Popeil Brothers, Inc. v. Schick Electric, Inc. | 356 F. Supp. 240, Nos. 70 C 295, 71 C 591, 71 C 97 | 11/14/1972 | Plaintiff | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Business Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 34 | Eli Lilly and Company, Inc. v. Generix Drug Sales, Inc., Caribe Chemical Company, Inc., Ellencee Pharmaceutical Laboratories, Inc., (Three Cases) | 460 F.2d 1096, Nos. 71-1797, 71-2642 and 71-2771. | 05/18/1972 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 35 | Cataphote Corporation v. Desoto Chemical Coatings, Inc. | 450 F.2d 769, No. 25118. | 01/17/1972 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 36 | Deere & Company v. Hesston Corporation, Hesston of Texas, Inc. | 440 F.2d 904, No. 29768. | 04/13/1971 | Plaintiff-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 37 | Air-Shields, Inc. v. Air Reduction Company | 331 F. Supp. 673, No. 67 C 1767. | 03/18/1971 | Defendant | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Business Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 38 | Illinois Tool Works, Inc. v. Sweetheart Plastics, Inc., Maryland Cup Corporation, and Sweetheart Cup Corporation | 436 F.2d 1180, No. 18215. | 02/22/1971 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 39 | Magnetics, Inc. v. The Arnold Engineering Company | 438 F.2d 72, No. 18182. | 02/17/1971 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 40 | Phil E Weiss Deceased By Mildred L Weiss Administratrix And Abraham | 425 F.2d 772, No. 8290. | 07/30/1970 | Cros-appellant / Appellee | Court of Customs and Patent Appeals | Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 41 | Hazeltine Research, Inc., and Counter-Defendant v. Zenith Radio Corporation, and Counter-Claimant | 418 F.2d 21, Nos. 15246, 15563. | 10/27/1969 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 42 | King-Seeley Thermos Co. v. Aladdin Industries, Incorporated | 418 F.2d 31, No. 470, Docket 32871. | 07/31/1969 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 43 | General Instrument Corporation v. Hughes Aircraft Company | 399 F.2d 373, No. 6999. | 07/18/1968 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the First Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 44 | Tibbetts Industries, Inc. And George C. Tibbetts v. Knowles Electronics, Inc. And Hugh S. Knowles | 386 F.2d 209, No. 16099. | 03/04/1968 | Plaintiff-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 45 | Hazeltine Research Inc And Counter Defendant v Zenith Radio | 388 F.2d 25, Nos. 15246, 15247, 15563, 15564. | 01/23/1968 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 46 | Bishman Manufacturing Co. And George T. Hemmeter v. Stewart-Warner Corporation | 380 F.2d 336, No. 15916. | 10/16/1967 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 47 | Hughes Aircraft Co. v. General Instrument Corp. | 275 F. Supp. 961, No. 3095. | 07/19/1967 | Plaintiff | District Court, D. Rhode Island | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 48 | Eli Lilly and Company v. Edward J. Brenner, Commissioner of Patents | 375 F.2d 599, No. 20083. | 03/29/1967 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit | Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 49 | The Plastic Contact Lens Company, a Corporation v. George H. Butterfield, Sr. | 366 F.2d 338, No. 20212. | 10/06/1966 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 50 | United States Rubber Company v. Borg-Warner Corporation | 360 F.2d 861, No. 15432. | 05/04/1966 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Criminal | -- | Win | Details |
| 51 | Cataphote Corporation, a Corporation v. De Soto Chemical Coatings, Inc., a Corporation | 358 F.2d 732, No. 19827. | 03/28/1966 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 52 | Cataphote Corporation, a Corporation v. De Soto Chemical Coatings, Inc., a Corporation | 356 F.2d 24, No. 19827. | 02/08/1966 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 53 | Eli Lilly and Company v. Brenner | 248 F. Supp. 402, No. 2817-64. | 12/06/1965 | Plaintiff | District Court, District of Columbia | Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 54 | The Ekco Products Company, Inc. v. Chicago Metallic Manufacturing Company | 347 F.2d 453, No. 14859. | 06/17/1965 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 55 | Union Carbide Corporation v. Graver Tank & Mfg. Co., Inc., and the Lincoln Electric Company, Union Carbide Corporation v. The Lincoln Electric Company | 345 F.2d 409, Nos. 14469-70. | 04/09/1965 | Defendant-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 56 | Hazeltine Research, Inc. v. Zenith Radio Corporation | 239 F. Supp. 51, No. 59-C-1847. | 01/25/1965 | Defendant-counterclaimant | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Business Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 57 | Application of Charles H. Goodman, Edward K. Rice, Klaus Rosenstern and George W. Lenzie | 339 F.2d 228, No. 7250. | 12/17/1964 | Appellant | Court of Customs and Patent Appeals | Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 58 | The Ekco Products Company, Inc. v. Chicago Metallic Manufacturing Company | 321 F.2d 550, No. 13770. | 08/16/1963 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 59 | King-Seeley Thermos Co. v. Aladdin Industries, Incorporated | 321 F.2d 577, No. 284. | 07/11/1963 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 60 | General Electric Company v. Sciaky Bros., Inc. | 304 F.2d 724, Nos. 14464-65. | 06/27/1962 | Plaintiff-appellant | Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit | Appeal Business Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 61 | American Thermos Prod. Co. v. Aladdin Industries, Inc. | 207 F. Supp. 9, No. 7320. | 06/26/1962 | Defendant | District Court, D. Connecticut | Business Civil | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 62 | Admiral Corporation v. Zenith Radio Corporation | 296 F.2d 708, No. 6592. | 11/15/1961 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 63 | Serge A. Scherbatskoy v. United States Steel Corporation and Sperry Rand Corporation | 287 F.2d 552, No. 13129. | 03/09/1961 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Criminal | -- | Loss | Details |
| 64 | Minnesota Mining & Mfg. Co. v. Plymouth Rubber Co. | 178 F. Supp. 591, No. 54 C 1115. | 03/27/1959 | Defendant | District Court, N.D. Illinois | Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 65 | Charles R. Pollard, Jr., D. B. A. Lytron Distributing Company, and Plastoid Corporation v. American Phenolic Corporation | 219 F.2d 360, No. 6848. | 02/15/1955 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 66 | Guy Edmond Weir v. Jerome J. Gordon | 216 F.2d 508, No. 11995. | 10/06/1954 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 67 | United Mattress MacHinery Co., Inc. v. Handy Button MacHine Co | 207 F.2d 1, No. 11020. | 10/16/1953 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 68 | Hopkins v. Waco Products, Inc. Alan's Sales Engineers v. Hopkins | 205 F.2d 221, No. 10780. | 06/23/1953 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 69 | Beltone Hearing Aid Co. v. American Sound Products, Inc | 203 F.2d 782, No. 10736. | 05/01/1953 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
| 70 | Gordon v. Weir | 111 F. Supp. 117, No. 8176. | 03/19/1953 | Plaintiff | District Court, E.D. Michigan | Business Civil Contract | -- | Undetermined | Details |
| 71 | Union Carbide & Carbon Corp. v. Graver Tank & Mfg. Co., Inc. | 196 F.2d 103, No. 10532. | 06/02/1952 | Appellant | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 72 | Chalupa v. Armour & Co | 188 F.2d 473, No. 207. | 04/23/1951 | Appellee | Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 73 | Hueter v. Compco Corporation | 179 F.2d 416, No. 10004. | 02/03/1950 | Defendant-appellee | Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | Appeal Civil | -- | Win | Details |
| 74 | Bendix Aviation Corporation v. Kury | 88 F. Supp. 243, No. 9652. | 01/17/1950 | Plaintiff | District Court, E.D. New York | Civil | -- | Loss | Details |
Contact
Dugald
S.
Mcdougall
Chicago
Per our terms of service (link below), any systematic or automated data collection from this website is strictly prohibited.
